Sunset Beach Hotel, Shelter Island

Shelter Island Restaurants

Great Eats – Shelter Island Restaurants

It’s been a tough summer 2020 for restaurants on Shelter Island.  Let’s hope that the 2021 season is AWESOME on this beloved island!

Shelter Island may be small, but there is no shortage of great Shelter Island restaurants. The foodie in you will be delighted. Menus range from delicious Italian to fresh local seafood. Of course, you must taste the excellent local east end wines.

Restaurants on Shelter IslandShelter Islad

As a matter of fact, local oysters are on most menus. My recommendation is to try Peconic Gold Oysters – they are delicious and right from the local waters! Let me introduce you to some of the best restaurants on Shelter Island – many of which are in some terrific hotels.

Pridwin Beach Hotel RestaurantPridwin Restaurant Shelter Island

Waterfront Dining – Romantic
The Pridwin serves delicious new America cuisine. You will have one of the best views on the island when you dine on the balcony of this restaurant. Moreover the menu has wonderful choices and the food is excellent.

Sunset Beach Restaurant

Sunset Beach Hotel, Shelter Island

Waterfront Dining – DJ – Dancing
This chic, beach restaurant serves French classics with an emphasis on fresh seafood. This is a trendy Shelter Island hot-spot. Definitely try the mussels – they are delicious! You must make reservations in advance, even for lunch.

Salt Waterfront Bar & GrillSalt

Waterfront Dining – Live Music at the Shipwreck Bar
Salt Bar & Grill is a casual but stylish restaurant located on a beautiful canal and the Island Boatyard. The restaurant focuses on fresh and local foods. It has a great ambience and very good food.

Vine Street CafeShelter Island

This restaurant is far from a cafe. It is a popular restaurant with a sophisticated menu and excellent food. It serves an evolving chef’s menu with seafood and a local seasonal menu. Many celebrities have been spotted here!

Caci Shelter IslandCaci

Caci is a newly opened restaurant in Shelter Island House. The chef focuses on seasonally inspired northern Italian cuisine. Fine ambiance and food awaits you with indoor or outdoor dining.

Hope you enjoyed this restaurant tour!! Let’s have a great 2021 season!!!

Shelter Island

Destination Shelter Island

Shelter Island is located between Greenport and Sag Harbor on the east end of Long Island. It is definitely a hidden gem and a perfect summer vacation spot. Many people decide to make it their year-round home. In the first place, you’ll discover a wonderful mix of natural beauty, gorgeous beaches and beautiful wildlife. Shelter IslandSecondly, there are many delicious restaurants, a few hotspots and lots of fun. Let’s not forget sports. Shelter is a boaters paradise and a golfers haven. In addition kayaking, stand up paddle boarding and other water sports are available. Shelter IslandFurthermore one of the best ways to explore the island is by bicycle. Many hotels offer complimentary bicycles. Therefore you can get some exercise before hitting the beach. There is something to do for everyone on Shelter Island. Let’s start exploring……

Getting to Shelter Island

. The only way to reach Shelter Island is by ferry or boat. There are two ferry stations on Shelter: the North (Greenport) and the South (Sag Harbor). My favorite way to get here is from Greenport via the LIE and Sound Avenue. It is a pleasure to pass all the beautiful wineries and lively farm stands. The ferry ride is about 5 minutes.  Alternatively, you can also take Sunrise Highway into Sag Harbor and then ferry (three minutes) to Shelter Island.
North Ferry Prices:
One way vehicle + driver $11. Same day roundtrip $16. Passengers in vehicles or on foot $2
South Ferry Prices:
One way vehicles $14. Same day roundtrip $17. Passengers in vehicles or on foot  $1

Shelter Island Sights

Shelter Island

Stars Cafe – a great little breakfast place

 

Shelter Island Shelter Island

BEACHES

Shelter Island Crescent Beach

Crescent Beach

My favorite beach is Crescent Beach. You will find a beautiful view, calm water and many yachts and sailboats. Not only can you play volley ball on the sand and indulge in various water sports, but  there is a huge tent for massages on the beach. In addition, you can cross the road and have lunch or a drink at Sunset Beach Restaurant.

Silver Beach, Shell Beach, Wades Beach, Upper Beach and Lower Beach are beautiful and quiet. These are typically in residential neighborhoods and used by the residents.

Sleep – Shelter Island Hotels and Guesthouses

There are a handful of great hotels and guesthouses here, so book early – especially on July 4th or Labor Day weekends. Read on for some of my favorite picks.

Sunset Beach Hotel

Sunset Beach Hotel

Escape to Sunset Beach and you’ll feel like you’re waking up in a different world.  Feel a European vibe in this unique, charming hotel located on Crescent Beach. Large studio rooms all have spacious sundecks facing the bay. Enjoy complimentary beach chairs with towels, bicycles and paddleboards. Play petanque and pingpong.

Sunset Beach Hotel, Shelter Island

Sunset Beach’s restaurant

Sunset Beach has a terrific outdoor lounge area with a fire pit and occasional live music. The three-level restaurant and bar area are always filled with a lively crowd.  Rosé wine is flowing and a Frosé  is perfect on a hot summer day. Of course, DJ music plays from the afternoon into the wee hours of the night. Being right on the beach makes this the ultimate spot with a French twist.

The Pridwin HotelShelter Island

The Pridwin reminds me of a grand hotel. It has a huge lobby, very nice rooms and a pool.  In addition, the upstairs balcony has one of the best dining views on the island, and great food. It is a 5 min walk to Sunset Beach, which is a hot spot both day and night.

Shelter Island House Shelter Island Hotels

You will discover casual sophistication and a chance to explore the local feel without sacrificing luxury. The property has a pool and is close to Crescent Beach. The property opened a delicious new restaurant, Caci.

West Neck Guest HouseShelter Island Hotels

West Neck Guesthouse, is only about two years old. The property offers comfy and beautifully appointed guest rooms all with king beds, private baths, flat screen TV’s with cable, and Wi-Fi. Just a 10 minute walk from Crescent Beach.

 

For EATS  go to: Shelter Island Restaurants

Shelter Island Hotels

Shelter Island Hotels

Sleep – Shelter Island Hotels and Guesthouses

Once you discover Shelter Island, you will definitely want to stay for awhile. Since the Island is small, there are only a handful of Shelter Island hotels, many of which have excellent restaurants. My favorite is the Sunset Beach Hotel. Remember to BOOK EARLY – especially on July 4th or Labor Day weekends. In addition, there are several Shelter Island Guesthouses that are wonderful. Read on for some of my favorite picks in wonderful Shelter Island.

Sunset Beach Hotel

Sunset Beach Hotel

Escape to Sunset Beach and you’ll feel like you’re waking up in a different world.  Feel a European vibe in this unique, charming hotel located on Crescent Beach. Large studio rooms all have spacious sundecks facing the bay. Enjoy complimentary beach chairs with towels, bicycles and paddleboards. Play petanque and pingpong.

Sunset Beach Hotel has a terrific outdoor lounge area with a fire pit and occasional live music. The three-level restaurant and bar area are always filled with a lively crowd.  Rosé wine is flowing and a Frosé  is perfect on a hot summer day. Of course, DJ music plays from the afternoon into the wee hours of the night. Being right on the beach makes this the ultimate spot with a French twist.

The Pridwin HotelShelter Island

The Pridwin reminds me of a grand hotel. Classic and timeless. BONUS- it was just completely renovated for the 2022 season. It has a huge lobby, very nice rooms and a beautiful new pool.  In addition, the balcony has one of the best dining views on the island. Moreover the food is delicious.  It is a short 10 min walk to Sunset Beach Hotel, which is a hot spot both day and night.

The Chequit Hotel

The totally renovated Chequit Hotel is now a beautiful a terrific option on Shelter Island. You are right in the village. Moreover you can walk to the North Ferry then continue directly into Greenport. You are not on the beach, but they will have ebike rentals-check on that if you book.

Shelter Island House Shelter Island House

You will discover casual sophistication and a chance to explore the local feel without sacrificing luxury. Shelter Island House has a pool and is close to Crescent Beach. The property just opened a delicious new restaurant, Caci.

West Neck Guest HouseShelter Island Hotels

West Neck Guesthouse, is another option on the island. The property offers comfy and appointed guest rooms all with king beds, private baths, flat screen TV’s with cable, and Wi-Fi. Just a 10 minute walk from Crescent Beach.